DHS Proposes Ending USCIS Deference to Prior Work Petition Approvals
By C. Matthew Schulz
On October 14, 2026, the U.S. Department of Homeland Security (DHS) proposed ending the requirement that U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) give weight to its own prior eligibility determinations when deciding certain Form I-129 petitions. The change would reach H-1B, L-1, O-1 and other temporary worker classifications. It would affect familiar cases such as an employer seeking to keep the same worker in the same job, and officers could still consider earlier approvals when relevant.
The Federal Register published Removing Deference to Prior USCIS Determinations of Eligibility, 91 Fed. Reg. 65119 (Oct. 14, 2026). The comment period closed November 13, 2026, under Docket USCIS-2026-0529.
Media coverage includes The Dallas Express, The Times of India, The Economic Times and Hindustan Times. In Forbes, Stuart Anderson examined DHS’s analysis of denial rates. The U.S. Chamber of Commerce filed comments opposing repeal.
History of the USCIS Deference Policy
USCIS introduced the policy in April 2004. The agency had found that some officers routinely reopened eligibility questions on extensions even when the underlying facts stayed the same.
The April 2004 Yates memorandum told officers to defer to earlier eligibility determinations in extension cases involving the same petitioner, worker and facts, subject to exceptions.
USCIS rescinded the guidance in October 2017 over concerns about the petitioner’s burden of proof and officers’ ability to investigate.
In April 2021, USCIS restored deference and incorporated it into the Policy Manual. DHS’s account of the 2004 and 2017 memoranda · USCIS’s 2021 policy alert
DHS codified the policy in its December 2024 H-1B modernization rule, which took effect January 17, 2025.
Despite the rule’s title, the provision reaches beyond H-1B extensions. The final rule applies the same standard to other eligible Form I-129 filings, including requests for a change of status, amendment or consular notification, whenever the same parties and underlying facts are involved.
DHS now proposes to remove that provision and says USCIS would revise its guidance accordingly if DHS finalizes the repeal. 2024 modernization rule, 89 Fed. Reg. 103054, 103092–94 · 2026 proposed repeal
What Deference Requires
When the same employer files for the same worker on the same underlying facts, USCIS gives weight to its own earlier determination of eligibility. An officer may depart from that determination if the earlier approval contained a material error, if circumstances or eligibility requirements materially changed, or if new information materially undermines eligibility. The employer still bears the burden of establishing eligibility on the current filing. For example, if new evidence shows that the duties of a purportedly unchanged H-1B job differ materially from those in the earlier petition, USCIS can examine those duties and reach a different result. 8 C.F.R. § 214.1(c)(5) · 2024 final rule discussion
Under the Policy Manual, when an officer decides that deference is inappropriate, the officer must acknowledge the earlier approval and explain the reason in the denial, request for evidence or notice of intent to deny. When USCIS relies on previously unknown derogatory information to make an adverse decision, the applicable disclosure rule generally gives the petitioner an opportunity to respond. That process can bring a factual disagreement into the open while USCIS still has the case. USCIS Policy Manual, Vol. 2, Part A, Ch. 4 · 8 C.F.R. § 103.2(b)(16)(i)
Why USCIS Adopted Deference
USCIS said that departing from a prior approval has real consequences for employers and workers and raises concerns about consistency and predictability. DHS’s 2024 rulemaking also identified an efficiency benefit for the agency and petitioners. An officer can focus on continued eligibility and any material changes without routinely reopening questions USCIS already resolved on the same facts. DHS concluded at the time that officers retained authority to seek additional evidence and investigate suspected fraud. 2021 USCIS policy alert · 2024 final rule discussion, 89 Fed. Reg. at 103092–94
How Courts Have Examined Inconsistent Decisions
Even before the 2004 memo, courts expected immigration officials to explain some departures from prior approvals. In Tapis International, the former Immigration and Naturalization Service denied an H-1B extension for a showroom manager whose petition it had previously approved. A Massachusetts federal court found that the agency abused its discretion both in its analysis of the job and by failing to address the earlier approval. The court directed the agency to approve the petition. Tapis International v. INS, 94 F. Supp. 2d 172, 176–77 (D. Mass. 2000)
In Hakimuddin v. Department of Homeland Security, a Texas federal court considered an L-1A extension denial while the 2004 guidance was in effect. The court discussed the guidance’s exceptions and said USCIS likely would have had to explain its different treatment had the employer placed the earlier petitions before the agency. The employer had omitted those filings from the record, and the court upheld the agency’s treatment of the prior approvals. The case shows why the underlying filings matter when a petitioner claims the facts stayed the same. Hakimuddin v. DHS, No. 4:08-cv-1261 (S.D. Tex. 2009)
In Fogo de Chao, the D.C. Circuit considered an L-1B petition for a Brazilian steakhouse chef. The court recognized that a sufficiently established pattern of earlier approvals might require USCIS to explain why it treated comparable cases differently. The restaurant had cited hundreds of earlier approvals, but the record lacked evidence showing that those petitions were factually and legally comparable. The court rejected the inconsistency claim on that record and remanded on other grounds, including the agency’s treatment of culturally acquired skills. Fogo de Chao (Holdings) Inc. v. DHS, 769 F.3d 1127, 1144–46 (D.C. Cir. 2014)
India House shows how close scrutiny of an inconsistent decision can survive without a deference policy. During the 2017–2021 rescission, USCIS denied an H-1B petition for a promoted restaurant manager after twice approving petitions for the same employer and worker in an earlier role. The government pointed to the difference in roles but did not explain why the more senior position failed to qualify. The Rhode Island federal court treated the unexplained inconsistency as part of its analysis of the evidence and held that the denial was arbitrary and capricious. India House, Inc. v. McAleenan, 449 F. Supp. 3d 4 (D.R.I. 2020)
Repeal Is Poor Policy
The existing rule gives USCIS a way to correct mistakes while making routine extensions more predictable.
A business deciding who will lead a project and a family deciding where to live both have to act before USCIS rules on the next petition. They can account for a change in duties or eligibility requirements. It is much harder to plan around the possibility that another officer will assess essentially the same evidence and reach a different result without explaining the difference.
DHS’s own analysis estimates that repeal could generate about 6,044 additional requests for evidence a year, based on an estimated increase of 2.9 percentage points.
DHS also found that petitions receiving an evidence request took an average of 64 days longer than petitions without one in fiscal years 2022–2025. The comparison measures an association, and some of that gap may reflect the complexity of cases that draw requests.
Even so, DHS itself expects that added review could prolong uncertainty about staffing and continued work authorization. DHS’s historical comparison found no corresponding change in denial rates across the Form I-129 groups it studied. Proposed rule, Table 3 and discussion of unquantified costs, 91 Fed. Reg. at 65127–29
The U.S. Chamber of Commerce points to a different measure. It notes that the H-1B denial rate for continuing employment rose from 5% in fiscal year 2017 to 12% in fiscal years 2018 and 2019. Those figures describe what happened in one category after the 2017 rescission. DHS’s analysis compares changes across broader groups of I-129 petitions over different periods. The H-1B trend shows why employers are concerned, but the year-to-year figures alone cannot isolate the effect of ending deference. U.S. Chamber of Commerce comments · Proposed rule, Table 3
If DHS repeals the rule, courts reviewing final agency action under the Administrative Procedure Act can still ask whether USCIS gave a reasoned explanation for a different result, especially when the record establishes that the cases are materially comparable.
A separate challenge to a final repeal could test whether DHS reasonably explained its reversal and adequately considered serious reliance interests.
DHS acknowledges employer and worker reliance in the proposal and says its enforcement concerns outweigh it. That judgment would be part of the record a court reviews. Judicial review can address an arbitrary decision after the fact, by which time an employer or worker may already have absorbed the delay and expense. 5 U.S.C. § 706 · DHS v. Regents of the University of California, 591 U.S. 1 (2020) · Proposed rule, Section III.E
Would Ending Deference Prevent Fraud or Abuse?
DHS argues that officers may read the current rule as a signal to scrutinize repeat filings less closely. That could make it easier for an employer to carry forward a false claim from the original petition or conceal a material change. Either would justify closer review under the current standard once USCIS has evidence of it. The question is whether removing the default would help officers uncover enough otherwise missed misconduct to justify reviewing routine cases more intensively. Proposed rule, Sections III.B–D
DHS cites administrative and targeted site visits in H-1B and L-1A extension cases. Among H-1B sites visited, the share where USCIS found fraud or noncompliance rose from 16.77% in fiscal years 2018–2020, when deference was off, to 22.39% in fiscal years 2022–2025, after USCIS restored it. The corresponding L-1A figures were 18.37% and 24.46%. The figures combine fraud with other noncompliance and describe the sites USCIS visited. Changes in site selection, enforcement priorities or the mix of filings could affect what inspectors found. The comparison leaves open how much fraud deference allowed or how much repeal would prevent. And the estimated increase in evidence requests measures added scrutiny, without showing how often that scrutiny uncovers fraud. Proposed rule, Section III.C and Table 3
DHS has a narrower option. It can retain the existing standard, train officers on when to invoke its exceptions, and direct site visits and requests for evidence toward discrepancies that bear on eligibility. It can then measure how often those inquiries confirm fraud or material noncompliance. That approach would give the agency better evidence about where additional scrutiny pays off while preserving a predictable process for employers and workers whose facts remain the same.
Related SchulzLaw Reading
Articles
- Professional Pathways to America: A Guide to the Most Often Used Work Visas and Green Cards. An overview of H-1B, O-1 and other work visas.
- Pathways to America for Extraordinary Talent. O-1 eligibility, evidence and sponsorship.
- Strategic Immigration Pathways for Entrepreneurs. L-1A transfers for multinational executives and managers.
Blog Posts
- H-1B and L-1 Extension Fees Rise: $4,000–$4,500 Surcharges and a New Form I-129. Extension fees for covered employers and changes to Form I-129.
- USCIS’s New Adjustment of Status Memo: Discretion, “Administrative Grace,” and the Limits of Agency Power. How dual intent applies to H-1B and L-1 workers pursuing permanent residence.